Jump to content

Sig Battles (ENTRIES/VOTING ONLY)


chrisco97

Recommended Posts

Dang, another tough descision...

Weylin: 0

csm725: 1

I have to go with csm because it is probably their first time at a render sig, and it turned out well.

Don't get me wrong Weylin, it is probably your best yet. I would have voted for you if it wasn't their first try.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, tough decision. I love futuristic vehicles and stuff, but I also love shiny metal things. xD

I really can't tell exactly what kind of vehicle that is though. Reminds me of a submarine.

I s'pose I have to go with Weylin. It's just... so... shiny... *stares*

Weylin: 1

csm725: 1

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ooooh, two very nice sigs.

Let's see:

pdnnoob:

Colors 13/17

Text 11/17

Texture/Fractal 9/13

Border 10/13

Composition 23/30

Flair 6/10

Total 72/100

Weylin:

Colors 11/17 (-2)

Text 14/17 (+3)

Texture/Fractal 10/13 (+1)

Border 7/13 (-3)

Composition 23/30 (E)

Flair 7/10 (+1)

Total 72/100

Wow, that helped. And no, I didn't do that on purpose.

I give it to Weylin

Sharper signature, but a very close battle:

Weylin 1

pdnnoob 0

Link to post
Share on other sites

Both of you have made approx. the same mistakes you made last time.

ptuZ, your colors are too bright and is that an autostereogram?

Siddek, the sig itself is pretty good, but the text is not.

E - More detailed critique

ptuZ:

Colors: 3/17 - Too bright!!!

Text: 8/17 - Albeit having no flow, it calms my eyes down a little.

Texture/Fractal: 9/13 - Hmmm, bright and repetitive, no thanks. Still an OK texture.

Border: 5/13 - This calls for a border of some sort.

Composition: 15/30 - "Overall not a bad sig, but could use a bit more fillers and better text" - that and the colors!

Flair: 2/10 - Nothing especially special...

Total: 42/100

Siddek:

Colors: 14/17 (+11) - "I really [like] the color scheme, it sticks to one general palette and looks great with the sig overall..."

Text: 5/17 (-3) - The same text again!? Well in this case it doesn't fit, maybe run a Sepia on it or something...

Texture/Fractal: 9/13 (E) - Seems just a bit flat, but not bad.

Border: 8/13 (+3) - "Just a simple plain black border about 3px wide, not much flair there but it does it's job well..."

Composition: 22/30 (+7) - The text!!! It burns!!! Otherwise, not a bad sig.

Flair: 4/10 (+2) - Quite a monotonous color scheme and the bright text kills it.

Total: 62/100

Siddek 2

ptuZ 0

Link to post
Share on other sites

Shouldn't it be Siddek - 2?

Anyways, here goes my first advanced critique: (based off of csm's one)

ptuZ:

Colors: 9/17 - Too bright, and maybe stick to a few colors instead of all of them -_-

Text: 4/17 - Doesn't flow with the sig at all, sorry

Texture/Fractal: 11/13 - I have to say that's a pretty cool texture design

Border: 7/13 - There really is no designated border but that fact doesn't totally ruin the sig

Composition: 18/30 - Overall not a bad sig, but could use a bit more fillers and better text

Flair: 4/10 - Not much of a mesmerizing sig

Total: 53/100

Siddek:

Colors: 16/17 (+7) - I really the color scheme, it sticks to one general palette and looks great with the sig overall

Text: 14/17 (+10) - I love the glowy effect of the text, the way it pops out at you, and the color is perfect to match the sig

Texture/Fractal: 12/13 (+1) - I really like the distorted hex grid overtop the map tutorial, it just looks sweet :D

Border: 9/13 (+2) - Just a simple plain black border about 3px wide, not much flair there but it does it's job well

Composition: 27/30 (+9) - Really decent sig overall, lots of flow and good colors.

Flair: 7/10 (+3) - It's an amazing sig that pops out at you and it's so hard not to look at it.

Total: 85/100

Siddek - 3

ptuZ - 0

#Winner: Siddek

Please remember to take my criticism constructively. ptuZ, you make some really nice work for a beginner like you, and you will get good soon, just keep trying! If you learn from my response, you might make a decent sig, but don't feel bad if at first it doesn't work out.

Link to post
Share on other sites

csm - 2

punishr - 1

That was hard. The saturated colors mixed with the chrome look in CSM's make it look great, while in punishr's, all the glows and the colors make it look good, too.

But since punishr's is still pixelated, I vote for CSM.

And I have to say, they're both top notch sigs.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...