Sign in to follow this  
chrisco97

Sig Battles (ENTRIES/VOTING ONLY)

Recommended Posts

PDNNoob: 1

Timmons106: 0

I love the planet and starscape in Pdnnoob's.

Timmon's render is aliased, plus the text is bad.

Ditto!

PDNNoob 3

Timmons 0

#winner PDNNoob

Edited by csm725

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I'll enter with my current as well:

Abstract_Final_Fantasy.png

Very nice signature so I wouldnt expect to win, but its good to keep these threads moving :).

Edited by K_I_N_G

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

K_I_N_G: 1

Falken: 0

King, the whole thing flows, and the c4ds match the sig nicely. Just get a better placement of the font, and it will be great!

Falken, not that it's bad, but I like King's better. The thing about your's is it is empty, and the text is sorta odd. But, good sig.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

K_I_N_G: 1

Falken: 0

King, the whole thing flows, and the c4ds match the sig nicely. Just get a better placement of the font, and it will be great!

Falken, not that it's bad, but I like King's better. The thing about your's is it is empty, and the text is sorta odd. But, good sig.

I agree about Falken but King's sig is perfect. Therefore my vote goes to KING.

2-nil KING

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Falken fantastic design i like the simplicity of it......... yet you can read volumes......

K_I_N_G.... have to saay excellent image..... but another stock rendered through with textures is great but my vote has to go to the most imaginitive

Really sorry king

Falken: 2

K_I_N_G: 2

Good Luck To Both.......

And remember to have fun or dont do it........... lol Siddek

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

falken: 2 // nice space theme, very clean & cold colours. I like how the image portrays an underwater feeling, although the image is of outer space...

k_i_n_g: 3 // like this better though, love the anime style. Colour scheme complements the overall feel of the image well, and the composition is balanced.

#winner k_i_n_g

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

n d: 0

Mayor_McSteeze: 1

@n d, I could recreate the image exactly as you have it from scratch. Im sure many here can, and the signature just seems like you may want to return to the basics. Looks like it was done in a hurry without the final touches that make a signature a finished product. To me that just means it doesnt seem finished yet. But hope this wasn't discouraging, just mean that you should attempt a few of the tutorials on creating a signature and get an idea of what I mean by taking your time.

@Mayor_McSteeze, Nice. The borders and the blurred surroundings add a nice touch, the text is nicely done as well. (And yes I realize how short that is, but I cant tell whats stock image and whats a part of the manipulations. Which usually means theres little work done to it -in which I dont believe thats the case- or its simply done very well.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

nd: 1

Mayor_McSteeze: 1

Sure, ND's is easy to make, but I like the feel and the zoom effect the text has. It shows tons of creativity.

Mayor's is just a manipultation. I know he can do better, so I am voting for ND here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

n d: 0

Mayor_McSteeze: 1

@n d, I could recreate the image exactly as you have it from scratch. Im sure many here can, and the signature just seems like you may want to return to the basics. Looks like it was done in a hurry without the final touches that make a signature a finished product. To me that just means it doesnt seem finished yet. But hope this wasn't discouraging, just mean that you should attempt a few of the tutorials on creating a signature and get an idea of what I mean by taking your time.

@Mayor_McSteeze, Nice. The borders and the blurred surroundings add a nice touch, the text is nicely done as well. (And yes I realize how short that is, but I cant tell whats stock image and whats a part of the manipulations. Which usually means theres little work done to it -in which I dont believe thats the case- or its simply done very well.)

Agreed completely.

nd: 1

Mayor_McSteeze: 1

Sure, ND's is easy to make, but I like the feel and the zoom effect the text has. It shows tons of creativity.

Mayor's is just a manipultation. I know he can do better, so I am voting for ND here.

But overall, I feel that execution is more important than creativity, therefore:

n d: 1

MMS: 2

Edited by csm725

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gazek, There is already 2 entries so i will go with the Ptuz Vs. st1cki3 matchup.

Ptuz, I like the overall grungy-ness of the sig but the text doesn't fit very well and the right side is rather plain. I do like the concept though.

St1cki3: I like the clean approach on this one although it is a little plain. The border is a fantastic touch also. Therefore...

Ptuz: 0

St1cki3: 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ptuZ: 1

St1cki3: 1

@ptuZ like the concept, Grunge, Skull, Text whats no to love?

@St1cki3 Just ripples with color overlay / w/e

EDIT: Spelling

Edited by N00Bz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

St1cki3 2

ptuz 1

St1cki3's and ptuz's sigs are equal in execution, both nice. I feel that (assuming St1cki3's is 100% PdN), it is more creative.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

St1cki3 3

ptuz 1

Hard to judge, they're two totally different types of sigs. I don't think there is enough to see in ptuz's, where's St1cki3's flows easily, and catches the eye.

#winner St1cki3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This one's easy...

Mayor 1

DA 0

DA, oh yes, I can see you. I can see you too well with the colors of this sig. And is there even text in this sig?

Mayor, nice conversion of a PS tut, nothing special.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this