This is hard...both are good in their own ways. The only thing I do not like about Rookking's is that it is really empty because of all of the darkness on the left side. But I honestly love looking at it, really nicely done.
But the only thing I do not like about Mayor's is that it looks really crowded...and the text is placed awkward. Well, two things. (lol!) But I do like the lighting. I just think it needs to be cleaned up and given some more contrast.
Rookking - 1
Mayor McSteeze - 1