Okay, let me say something.
I like both works, somehow I have to be fair. In this case, I'm treating signatures like shops' signboards. It needs clarity to stand out and showing the corporate identity of the shop.
At the same time, I'm using seven elements of arts ( Lines, Space, Tone, Colours, Textures, Shapes & Forms ) and principles of designing ( Balance, Contrast, Emphasis, Movement, Pattern, Rhythm, Unity ) 'penalty shoot-out' to decide the winner.
Line (s )- Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Space- Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Tone - Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Colours- Limon 1 DrewDale 1
Shapes- Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Form- Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Textures- Limon 1 DrewDale 0
Balance- Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Contrast-Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Emphasis-Limon 0 DrewDale 1
Movement-Limon 1 DrewDale 0
Pattern-Limon 0 DrewDale 0
Rhythm-Limon 0 DrewDale 0
Unity- Limon 0 DrewDale 1
So, in Elements Of Arts Limon 2 DrewDale 6, and Principles Of Designing Limon 1 DrewDale 4. Speaking about the clarity of the signature, it goes to DrewDale.
So far I give DrewDale a fair winning this time.
Latest results : Limon 1 - DrewDale 1