Selections are not snapped to pixels

[Roly Poly Goblinoli]

I think it's best to illustrate what I mean through a picture, so I attached one (difficulty uploading it). Not much else to post except that I have Windows 7 32-bit. http://imgur.com/JfvPtRP

 

If you can't see the picture, it's at 3200x zoom and the selection tool is cutting through a pixel. I wrote the zoom incorrectly on the picture, by the way.

Edited July 6, 2014 by AnthonyScoffler

[Thorsby]

Have you tried to switch from Antialised selection quality to Pixelated selection quality? It's a new feature.

[Rick Brewster]

What tool did you use to draw the selection?

[zeromus]

I believe this user is being surprised by the anti-aliased selection. I'm not able to get angles like that without using an ellipse. I studied it because I pay close attention to pixel-editing bugs in paint.net and thought this might be interesting. Doesn't seem related to the zooming though.

 

I did find this, however: use the lasso tool to scribble a munged-up selection in a tiny area (with antialiased selection enabled).. try to keep it between 1x1 and 3x3. Scribble for several seconds, and then cut and paste. It may take several tries, but eventually you can get this exception:

 

System.AggregateException: One or more errors occurred. ---> System.ArgumentOutOfRangeException: must be non-negative
Parameter name: width:Int32=-25
   --- End of inner exception stack trace ---
   at PaintDotNet.Diagnostics.ValidationExtensions.ThrowValidationException(Validation validation) in D:\src\pdn\paintdotnet\src\Base\Diagnostics\ValidationExtensions.cs:line 955
   at PaintDotNet.Rendering.SizeInt32..ctor(Int32 width, Int32 height) in D:\src\pdn\paintdotnet\src\Base\Rendering\SizeInt32.cs:line 129
   at PaintDotNet.Actions.PasteAction.PerformActionImpl() in D:\src\pdn\paintdotnet\src\PaintDotNet\Actions\PasteAction.cs:line 356

...

 

While zoomed in, you can see that cutting and pasting anti-aliased selections cutting through pixels from an opaque image will result in semi-transparent pixels. It seems like copying and pasting opaque content should round-trip to an opaque result.

 

Sorry to stack so many topics in one thread, don't know if you can stand it.

[Rick Brewster]

Interesting! I was able to get that crash to repro. Well, that means I can fix it. For now, however, don't do that