Pretty tough... I'd say Mayor's is better, however. Drgrit, you name is too blurry and aliased in your graphic, but the rest is very creative and original. Mayor, while I hate that style it is definitely more eye appealing, even though it isn't very creative (C4Ds and smudging). Also, I am curious why you deleted the inside of the one lens and then left it aliased. Despite all that, I like yours better, Mayor. Drgrit, your day will come.
Mayor: 1
Drgrit: 0