Jump to content

avada

Members
  • Posts

    32
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by avada

  1. On 2016. 11. 14. at 11:08 PM, Rick Brewster said:

    PNG optimization is an excruciatingly slow process unless the image is very small.

     

    I've always recommended doing external PNG optimization as a "final pass" on your content creation. That is, do it after you're doing with all of your edits, before uploading it somewhere else.

     

    It'd save a fair bit of time if I wouldn't have to do it manually. Also pngoptimizer seems to be the fastest of the lot I tried

     

    On 2016. 11. 15. at 0:42 AM, Amaroq Dricaldari said:

    The problem with TinyPNG is that it lossily encodes the PNG, reducing the colors and other things like that.


    That is a problem. I most definitely don't want that with a PNG.

  2. On 2016. 10. 23. at 8:04 PM, Ego Eram Reputo said:

    I disagree. You need to plan your workflow to account for this, rather than relying on paint.net to save you.

    Here's what I do: I open an image and immediately decide if this edit will overwrite the original. If I want to keep the original, I use File >Save As... to specify a new filename and format before I do any editing.

     

    Your rationale would only make sense if only robots would use paint.net which isn't the case. Usually people press ctrl+s reflexively, in which case you end up overwriting a lossy file unrecovaribly. At least with lossy files you can recover the original, by undoing everything and saving it. The inability to undo a step with an image editor sucks a lot.

     

    If the user could specify a default save format, it would prevent such unexpected things from happening, but that's not possible either as far as I can tell.

     

    On 2016. 10. 26. at 5:37 PM, Rick Brewster said:

    Handy shortcut: Ctrl+Shift+S = Save As

     

    I'm aware of that. Yet if you press ctrl+s there's no going back, no matter if you decide to "save as" after. Well, the quality prompt helps a bit. (Not sure if it appeared for edited jpg-s when I reported this)

  3. Hi!

     

    I don't think it makes sense to the source format after I edited the image, if it's a lossy format. After I crop/resize an image I mostly want it losslessly.

    Even worse that I often accidentally overwrite the source file in these cases, which can't be recovered because it was lossy.

    In general I think it would make sense saving to work as save as (with a prompt, defaulting to png) in this case too, just like with a new file.

×
×
  • Create New...