Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Sfifer]

I like it, although i think if you used the black border and blended it with the picture it may look better.

Still it is amazing worthy of a 9.5/10 IMO

rate?

Edited September 29, 2010 by Sfifer

[Stone85]

It's really just a stock with some different coloring, but it looks ok. Maybe try to add some more.

7/10

[Sfifer]

If it helps I did take the photo

also yours is very interesting,i like the texture you used in the background.

the text looks great too

If there is anything wrong the border is a bit large but other then that Amazing dude great work.

9.5/10

rate?

Edited September 29, 2010 by Sfifer

[ptuZ]

pretty cool but as your current it just seems like a stock with some effects, still it's good

7/10

[chrisco97]

I have to say, best sig you have made. Definately my favourite. Just needs some effects on the render, and it will be great. 8/10.

[Stone85]

If it helps I did take the photo

also yours is very interesting,i like the texture you used in the background.

the text looks great too

If there is anything wrong the border is a bit large but other then that Amazing dude great work.

9.5/10

rate?

It sure does help, that is a great picture

Agreed on the border.

Chrisco, keep the border. 9.5/10

[Sfifer]

THanks, I found it hard to do something with the photo without making it look terrible.

Rate Stone

[Sharp]

A few comments.. There doesn't really seem to be any real flow, and you put the light source on the top when looking at the render it would be coming from left and down a little. Other than that, the blending and effects in general are well put together. 7.5/10

rate:

Edited September 30, 2010 by Sharp

[Mendo]

that is amazing sharp, it looks relatively simple at first glance, but now i think about it, there must have been a great deal of effort and time put into that..

the outlining of the text works really well. i like the way the blue gently fades out a little bit around the text in the middle.. great job 8.5 / 10

i made this one for a gaming website i regular.. and i know it's ridiculously over sized for a signature.. but it's closer to a signature than anything else..

rate:

[Mayor_McSteeze]

It's a little dark but other then that it flows really well although i would like to see some sort of light source to make something stand out. 7.5\10

Rate Current:

[csm725]

Liking the faux 3D, but the outline is a little too thick for me. Good shadow although it's cut off on the 'y'. The texture (diag. lines?) is a nice touch! 8.1/10

Edited October 2, 2010 by csm725

[Stone85]

9/10

Very clean, but could use some work around the render.

Rate:

[Mayor_McSteeze]

The text is amazing, i just thought i would throw that out there first because thats what i noticed, also, the render looks like its scrunched up at the top and its bothersome . But into more detail...

Text & Or Border 14/15

Color Scheme 7/10

Textures & C4d's 15\20

Compostion & Flow 12/15

Quality 7/10

Execution 8/10

Concept 8/10

Unique & Eyecatching 8/10

Overall 79/100 - C+

Please Rate:

Edited October 3, 2010 by Mayor_McSteeze

[Drgrit]

Mayor. Its very eyecatching and fresh. 9/10 for the smudging on the wrist and the mirror thing.

Rate this;

New material Why is it so big?

Edited October 3, 2010 by Drgrit

[Stone85]

Not my type of sig but it looks pretty cool. A little too bright, maybe a different color scheme so that I don't have to put on my . Lol

[chrisco97]

Love it, simply love it. 9.5/10

---

[Mayor_McSteeze]

Good flow and nice blending. The vignette is a little to strong though and border is a tad to thick. (But thats just me.)

Text is great, fits well into that "rocky" look.

7.8\10

[Stone85]

I'd give it higher than a 7.8

Mayor. I hate it. Kid Cudi's music is trash.

Kidding. Love it. Kid Cudi's one of my favorite rappers right now. Your text is getting better but I don't really like the way you smudged the collar.

8/10

Rate:

Anyone got any tips on how to colorize a Black and White sig? I failed...

Edited October 5, 2010 by Stone85

[csm725]

Erm... no tips, I like the colors. 7.5555/10! Nice text. Real good potential you have as an artist.

[Drgrit]

Jeez csm its so simple, but creative lol. You probably just randomly felt the urge to draw a very good 2 year old drawing xD

[Stone85]

LOL

Nice sig I like this one more. Looks like the text took a while. 8/10

(I really need to start a gallery instead of posting here..)

[chrisco97]

You have really got some great signatures. 9/10. The edges seem empty, if you would fix that, I would give it a 10/10.

---

Another new one!

Edited October 5, 2010 by chrisco97

[Stone85]

Wow thanks. Yeah that can be done. Maybe I will one day for a sig battle.

Love it. The splatters go perfect with the c4d. I could NEVER find anything to do with that render. 'Shift' isn't very visible though. Also, what is going on behind shift? It looks like a person lol.

9.25/1O (fix the text and you get 9.5 )

[yy10]

Pretty cool. Remove the text and the border and it'll be a lot better. Try to not add some blrury black brushes at the sides of the sig. If you want to make something darker, you can maybe add a layer, set to Colour Burn, and brush with a black brush on it. Gj, you're improving 7/10

Don't expect anything good here

[Drgrit]

@ stone I know eh?

yy10, that is really good. Is the background a render? Well, anyways good glowing.