Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Raptor_101]

Nice and clean however you didn't really need the site in the sig. It slightly distracts from the focus, however it's fine. Also there are .jpg artifacts that distract from it. 7/10.

[ImAnOwl?]

Dont get your sig rated 117 times :S.. (csm...)

i like the overall sig but the text is a bit off 7.5/10

[Skitzo]

@ImAnOwl?

I don't even know what the hell your sig is supposed to be, BUT, it does look

kinda neat. I'm betting there were about 300-59184 C4Ds used. Unlike other

people who just copy+paste,copy+paste, I can actually see you spent time

making it all fit in nice like a jigsaw puzzle. for that, i congratualte you. oh and

the text is alright..overall 9.123/10

[Raptor_101]

I like it with the exception that the stars weren't done correctly to compliment. However it's generally a nice sig. 7.8/10.

[0(-.-)0]

9/10

In my opinion, there is no flaw. Its just not the best you've ever done. Still amazing, just not the best.

[Servant_Of_Thor]

Its simple, so 5/10. Unless you made the arrow in PDN then I'd give you a 9/10; cause it is sweet!

[warfighter67]

If you made it in PDN than 10/10, If you used a stock than 8.5/10

Edited April 5, 2010 by Weylin

[himself22]

Ok, the whole top part is awesome, all the colors match up perfectly, you can read the text easily, but the bottom has some problems (in my opinion). I can't tell what the little button is between the facebook button and the hexagon rectangle. And I think it's kind of hard to read the Weylin side, I would just change the outside blur color. And one more thing, the whole lower side is beveled except for the Weylin rectangle (it just doesn't look right to me).

I'd give the top 10/10 and the bottom 7/10, with a total average of 8.5/10

By the way I like your avatar.

Please rate my current signature.

[Axle]

the planets are nice idea but one i have seen before, but the light coming through the middle is BRILLIANT and the left planet is nice the one on the right (i think thats earth) looks to unreal and cartoony which ruins the sig, the text should also be placed differently maybe. 7.341352/10

RATE >>>>>>>>

Edited April 5, 2010 by Axle

[chrisco97]

I like it, but WAY to simple. Add more to it! 6/10

[csm725]

Nice, smooth flow.

6.5/10

Current.

[0(-.-)0]

Brillo idea. Needs a border. NOW.

8/10

Second best sig of yours yet.

[csm725]

Brillo idea. Needs a border. NOW.

8/10

Second best sig of yours yet.

What's my best?

@Your sig - 6.5/10 , weird concept. Simple. Too simple, supposedly.

EDIT - You should know the background is derived from a stock image, i.e. it is a stock which was heavily edited (color tweaking, removal of stars, dramatification of zoom-blur in the middle). The Windows logo is traced.

Edited April 6, 2010 by csm725

[chrisco97]

I think the vector sig you used for your google site.

I LOVE it, it does need a border, than it would get a 10/10 from me!

------

Rate:

[0(-.-)0]

Its simple, so 5/10. Unless you made the arrow in PDN then I'd give you a 9/10; cause it is sweet!

Yep! PDN made arrow.

What's my best?

@Your sig - 6.5/10 , weird concept. Simple. Too simple, supposedly.

EDIT - You should know the background is derived from a stock image, i.e. it is a stock which was heavily edited (color tweaking, removal of stars, dramatification of zoom-blur in the middle). The Windows logo is traced.

Your best is indeed the Google vector sig.

Also, very impressive job on your current sig. Just not as good as your Google site vector sig.

I think the vector sig you used for your google site.

I LOVE it, it does need a border, than it would get a 10/10 from me!

------

Rate:

He is correct. Google sig all the way.

Next person rate Chrisco!

[Axle]

too simple and basic, 2.5/10

okay, this is not a sig but imagine my name was 'Mayal' so now that it is the current sig for my 'Mayal' character i want you to rate it.

[0(-.-)0]

Too big but nice, shiny, a touch aliased, but good idea. Slick. 7/10

[pipp92]

kinda like that

but bit too simple and not sleak enough

6/10

rate:

[Axle]

i like it but you have messed up the joint between his left shoulder (right shoulder when looking at it) when it merges into the warped redness, 7/10, (8/10 if you fix the fail join)

Rate:

[0(-.-)0]

Neatly done. Maybe green text though. And a border! A BORDER!

6/10

Kinda boring...

[Axle]

um, there is a border on it 0(-.-)0

[0(-.-)0]

Really? Sorry. I have bad eyes and I've been up all night The combination gives me an excuse for not seeing it. Oh well. The border bumps it up to 7.5

[jerry533482]

Decent 0(-.-)0, but I'd encourage you to add more to it. It's a tad too basic. I'd say 6.5/10

Okay, this sig is basically a crop out of, in my opinion, my best attempt at visualizing deep space. specifically, a star system.

[csm725]

Decent 0(-.-)0, but I'd encourage you to add more to it. It's a tad too basic. I'd say 6.5/10

Okay, this sig is basically a crop out of, in my opinion, my best attempt at visualizing deep space. specifically, a star system.

Based on realisticness (?), the sun's glow is a little artificial, as is the sun itself.

Asteroid's glow in top corner is very off.

Moon by itself is nice, just doesn't fit in overall.

Other planet is good. (bottom-right corner)

Nebulae in the background are artificial.

Overall, I've seen better pieces from you. 5.5/10

[ImAnOwl?]

Seem too simple... the windows thingy needs abit of AA... :huh: 5.5/10

rate this, tried to replicate a photoshop toon effect, took me quite a while...

it needs text.. it will be added later when i figure out what to write.. im not a manga freak i just found the render and thought that it looked cool

Edited April 6, 2010 by ImAnOwl?