Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[csm725]

Nice. Good flow, a little dull though. Render fits in nicely. 7.3333/10

[chrisco97]

I like the drop shadow, and the simplicity of it. It is simple, but awesome! 8/10

Rate:

[pipp92]

the bg looks good

the render looks just pasted on this good bg, lacks effects

and rotated text is never a good thing

6.5/10

rate which you like better:

[chrisco97]

I like the colored one better.

It is nice, many effects, and I like how simple the border is. 8/10

[iGreen]

9/10

Not much I can say, it's awesome and render seems to fit background well.

[chrisco97]

Thank...

5.8/10. It is nice, but the render needs a different place, and I do not like the smudging.

Rate:

[wes615]

Love the effects on the car. Nice background selection. However, the Mustang logo, the long neon light, the lights on the left, and the smoke takes away from the sig. 7.7/10

[Gamer_World14]

It's a bit simple, but I still think it looks ok. The apple looks cut out well, although I think you could place it somewhere else and get a better effect with the sig. 6.8/10

[chrisco97]

I love it! Nice job! Looks like a spacescape to me. I love the "GW" on the side. 8/10

Rate:

[csm725]

Everything is nice, but the font is iffy. Border is a no-no, 6.5/10. If you fixed the border, 7.5, possibly 8, out of 10.

[Sylar]

Nice! I like the reflection. 8.5/10

[flip]

Did you even make that sig?

Anyway, it's alright I guess. Looks too busy in my opinion. 6/10.

[csm725]

No, it seems like Soka's style + font.

And about your sig, it's nice, not the best, but very sharp. 7/10

[yy10]

Too simple. Anyone could do that with a 3D text tut. 6/10

[Sylar]

Did you even make that sig?

Anyway, it's alright I guess. Looks too busy in my opinion. 6/10.

No, soka made it.

And i like that sig^^^

9/10

[csm725]

It's okay. There is a seam between the two images, but otherwise, nice. 7/10

and @yy10, I didn't use a tutorial to make it.

[Sylar]

I think 8.5 still

[chrisco97]

I like the flow of the sig, but the tree at the bottom is completely out of place. And the font doesn't fit the render at all. 7/10

[yy10]

It's okay. There is a seam between the two images, but otherwise, nice. 7/10

and @yy10, I didn't use a tutorial to make it.

I'm just saying the style is too simple...anyone could make it.

Just a suggestion, maybe you could add dome c4d's below the text and make it look the the text is standing on them??

Again...extremely simple (noobish)

TPBM rate Chrisco

[flip]

csm and chricos... post some new sigs or just stop posting here because you've had yours rated at least 5-8 times.

[chrisco97]

@ Flip:

I just changed my sig two days ago. And, I mainly post to rate other peoples sigs and give them some advice.

Next person rate Flip.

[Sylar]

I like the flow of the sig, but the tree at the bottom is completely out of place. And the font doesn't fit the render at all. 7/10

Not a tree......

8/10

[sokagirl]

Okay , let me clarify this once and for all . That is no tree and there was no render used in creating that signature .

@ Sylar maybe you should put up a different signature for people to rate instead the same one over and over ..

[chrisco97]

@ Sylar: Sorry, it looks like a few cracks in the ground.

[Gamer_World14]

I like what you've done with the text, but I'd work on trying to get a better focal point, and have the border taken out or less noticeable. 7/10.

I will try and make a new signature in the future, so you don't have to keep rating this one.