Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[csm725]

To be honest with you, I don't really like it at all. Colors are boring, zoom blur on text is old. 2/10

[chrisco97]

I really like your new sig. The field is really nice. 9.5/10

[Ancient Shed]

Chrisco97's signature is really cool. Simple and beautiful 7/10.

My new entry ( I fail at making signatures -.-)

Hidden Content:

[csm725]

Nah, just way too confusing. Text effects are great, though, and I'll give you credit. 4.5/10

[Dark Zarosia]

I like it, just the goal posts are a little weird looking, angle wise.

Rate:

[crowbladezzz]

dark zarosia I like your sig (the image comes from an fanart from world of warcraft) 6.5/10

but I like your current more 7.0/10

rate this one please (created from scratch):

[chrisco97]

I really like it. It can have some improvement...but 8.5/10

[Willmuska]

Nice chrome effect, goes well with the C4. However, the font doesn't really match, try using a different font, make it lighter, duplicate it, put the duplicated layer under the orginal and blur it. It should look nicer. 8.5/10

[Dark Zarosia]

Meh. It's really just a re-coloured render slapped onto a background. The text is okay though.

Try using C4D's or brushes to help give it flow. Are you new at PDN? I see you only have 13 posts. If so, then thats not bad for a beginner.

5/10

[Ryberg360]

renders are not thing but that is cool. Background is sweet. 7/10

[chrisco97]

It's pretty good, alright. I like the tree. But I don't like the horror feel it has to it. (ignore that comment, I hate horror films) It is better than your avatar though. 6.5/10

[csm725]

Render is nice, maybe a color version? Font doesn't fit in though. The links at the bottom are definitely a nice touch, but there are better fonts to use than Arial, size 12 (or 10 or 14). 4.5/10

[Sharp]

Goal posts, gates, and numbers on the field all have off perspective, and add shading to the strings of the football so it looks more 3D. 5/10

[Dark Zarosia]

Simple and beutiful. Only thing for me is that it's really bright. Solid 8.5/10

[Frontcannon]

Really love the render, though the background could use some more colour. 6.7/10

[csm725]

Nice feel to it, background's symmetry is an added touch. I like the fire in the background, but the whole things just isn't my style. 5.5/10

[Willmuska]

.

Edited July 30, 2021 by Willmuska

[csm725]

Font is a little skinny and aliased. Render + background = ding ding ding we have a winner! So 5.5/10, good solid render sig.

EDIT: Oops. Typo. I meant 6.5

[Dark Zarosia]

@ Csm: This is absurd. You really like his signature, which is just a render slapped onto a boring background, yet you HATE mine which actually took some work? That background is like 90% PDN. You have a really weird view on signatures...

Next person rate Csm.

[chrisco97]

I would say a 5.5/10. It has agreat design, I like the 3D and evrything, but it is to simple.

[csm725]

@DZ Your background is PdN? Well sorry, most people with <100 posts don't have PdN made bg's in their sig. It helps to point that out. In that case, fine. 7.5/10. Good enough?

[r3b3l]

You can't please everyone guys. Do what suits YOU best and you've got a winner. All three of you have great sigs, DZ has some very nice creativity in his/hers. Love the colors. Chrisco has nice features integrated into the sig very cool to put links in there and I like the font and the colors. Personally Ive seen enough game themed sigs, but that's my opinion. CSM you have a unique sig it looks simple yet I know it wasn't. At least for me it wouldn't be. Nice color scheme and glossy look is great.

[toe_head2001]

3/10

You need get some inspiration, look at a lot of examples of what you want to do, then spend a good amount of time on your signature.

Then again, I understand if you want to have a simple signature up asap, rather than not have one at all, and wait till you make a really nice one.

[BoltBait]

toe_head2001, brilliant! 10/10

Your sig is a shining example to others as to what a sig should be.

BTW, csm725, your sig is very nice. Looks real. Nicely done!

[csm725]

I like the subtle advertising. and just cause I ADORE your plugins, 15/10.