Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Willmuska]

I wouldn't say it sucks, but I can't give it more than a 3.

It looks like a render that's been run through 4 effects and given a border. Sometimes that'll turn out well but in your case it mostly blurred the render. You should always try to keep your render sharp and easily distinguished. Instead of blurring the render, duplicate the layer and blur the bottom layer, that way you still have the colors fade from the render into the background but the render stays sharp. Be sure to check out the tutorials section and if you see someone with an awesome sig, PM them. Most people here are nice enough to reply back with a tip or two.

Thanks, I really needed to learn where to improve. I tried a different tutorial this time, and I think I got better results (a lot better).

Skip me!

[Zieon Eslador]

I've already rated csm725's sig, so, skip me.

burningrock, look at this picture for a second. :wink:

Notice anything? Besides, the split is 3/4th's a centimeter farther down. It does seem like an error with the text in place though.

Willmuska, you're right, that sig is much better than your previous one. It won't be long before you won't even need tutorials and can start experimenting as much as you want.

[yy10]

@Willmuska

Nice sig. Though the render is a bit stretched and it's too simple. Add some c4d's, brushes etc.....

[pipp92]

looks good but the size is a bit weird

it's one of my favourite stocks and i would like to see a vertical one out of it

8.5/10

[Frontcannon]

A bit more variety in colour would do this sig some good. Awesome stock though, 8/10.

[The Stranger]

The text can be a lot better and if the tag was some how smoothed out without all the criss-cross lines that would make it better as well. 6.5/10

[pipp92]

i really like this piece

the render blends good in and the text looks good

just i think your style is the same every time (C4D spamming)

8.9/10

rate:

[SkullSplitter]

Looks great. The effects are awesome but I think you should change the colors.

Pink doesn't quite fit the render in my opinion. 8.5/10

Rate:

[yy10]

Too plain. Looks like all you did was slap in a render and smudged and blurred it as a background. Add some other stuff and don't always stick to the same style. It looks so similar to all your other sigs. 7/10

[theonlychad]

great use of blend modes and effects and great flow. Has a very nice feel too it great job yy10 i like it so much i give you a 10/10

[flip]

It's pretty good. The second border is a little weird, though. The text is hard to see. But the marbles are pretty cool. Now shadows, though?

[Frontcannon]

You just gotta love that pastell effect. Artsy stuff, 9/10

[yy10]

Nice. You haven't changed your sig for a long time. I like all the abstract looking style thing, the colours fit well, good job. 8/10

For a tournament.

[flip]

Nice. I don't know anything about render sigs, but maybe add shadows to the circles to make it look more 3d? 9/10 though, looks good.

PS Frontcannon I didn't use the pastel effect.

[SkullSplitter]

I love it. Simple, elegant and very pretty.

I think the text is a little too big. It's a bit distracting. Otherwise great. 9/10

Rate:

[Frontcannon]

PS Frontcannon I didn't use the pastel effect.

You got me wrong there, I meant it looks like it

[Bjarni]

That's great Skullsplitter.

Maybe add an other border.

8.7|10

rate my current please

[Briamoth]

Nice. Like the colors as well as the blurred rectangle. The text is good. Love the reflection. 8.5/10

[Eclipsed]

9/10 Great job! the render of link is a bit blurry, but otherwise excellent. I really like the outline of him, it adds a nice touch.

Trying a new one:

[Bjarni]

Cool abstract, looks a bit pixelated, but it's still nice.

7.5|10

Rate my current please

[csm725]

I dunno, just a little too simple for me. Nice use of Dents (You did use Dents for the green-pink-blue part, right?)

The reflection is good but text is a little small. 8/10

[Willmuska]

Really nice knife, and same with the tofu and cutting board. I like the original design, the only thing that's bothering me is the tomato. I think you should add a shadow to it. My final rating is 8.5/10

[Bjarni]

@ CSM

Yes, I used dents

@ Wilmuska

Nice sig, background is abit boring, but the rest is fine, I really like the font.

8|10

Rate my current please

[yy10]

I like the simplicity of it. But the colours don't blend together and that glass block is actually green?! Maybe make the glass block Black and White and tone down all the colours. 7/10

[theonlychad]

love the new vector style yy10 i can see nothing at all wrong with it except for you could possibly make the vectors have a bit of depth by adding a bit of a drop shadow to different ones. 9.5/10