Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[SkullSplitter]

The font looks nice but the background is kinda dull. 5/10

[Sulivan]

hmm... ok.. overall nice.. 7/10

rate this

[Gigabyte]

You shoud'nt black'n'white it.. 6.5/10

Rate this:

[Mendo]

hmmmm very nice, maybe the flow could use some work but thats it...

oh and on your current sig :SHOCK: THAT, is freaking' Awesome! i love it.... 10/10 for the current gigabyte...

averyone knows that maximum size sigs are the best so just put my 10/10 in already jks, i don't really like the fact that i made it sooo big so rate it how you want, as i will most likely take no bearing on critisicm over this sig...

[sonicx7171]

9/10 Awesome! Very cool! that picture is so detailed where did you get it? (I won't rate it 10/10 because I'm a sonic fan and people might say just because I'm a sonic fan I rated it perfect)

[Mendo]

the picture is kind of basic and not really my type part but at least have the effects working and your giving things a a try i don't know what you could improve on because it's very simple, nice try 5/10

it's from planet renders, PM me if you want more info on it or if you want the cut out of sonic or anything else i can help you with.

by the way, you can find planet renders there >>>>> http://www.planetrenders.net

this is one i've just made, it's inspired by the nabster sig, with the sloping landscape i just wanted to see if i could create the same effect.

what yuu think?

[yy10]

nice sig medo, but the border is so killin it! the text is too erm...thin and it's rly too simple. imo, it's a photograph that's got text slapped on it. 7/10

and current

[SkullSplitter]

1: As I said before I can't really see any effects, except the light source above her head.

But the background fits the render and the text is good. Maybe you could try better blending on the render. 7/10

Current: Lots of colors but they clash a bit. The effects are good but there are a few weird-looking spots.

The text is good but the part of the underlines that go under the effects should be faded/erased.

[The Stranger]

7.5/10.

The text placement can be better, and the render's focal is kinda blurred. Nice work overall though. KIU

[Mendo]

wowzers that's really good stranger, render looks sweet background is nice and simple effects are clean, only problem, left side looks a little :AntiAliasingOff:

but aside from that great job mate. 8.5 / 10

rate current.

[Gigabyte]

8/10

Borders could be better and you coudda use more "nianses"* of blue.

*darker, lighter..

[Wilson]

7/10

The text is too blurry and the background is too busy. Put together, though, it does work. The text is the main issue for me though.

TPBM rate my current.

[theonlychad]

very good concept and your best to date, although it is a bit too glowy and the line in the middle could be taken away. Still good though so i give it a 7/10

[csm725]

I like the realistic and un-abstract approach, and isn't that Maple Origins?

EDIT: Forgot to rate, teehee. 8/10

[Wilson]

@theonlychad Thanks a lot. Liking your current too.

@csm725

8/10

Realistic signature, very good concept. Good text too.

[APShredder]

It's okay. To me it just looks like some grey boxes and lines with an overused font. 4/10

Rate:

[pipp92]

too simple and the bg is too empty 6/10

rate:

[csm725]

Background 100% PdN? If so 7.5/10. If not, then 6/10.

[ShK_828]

I think the sig would looks better if you just made the whole thing transparent, as there is not much going in the background.

chopping board + knife looks good, 8/10

[pipp92]

the blue is cool, so is the text

but i think the face looks a bit weird, dk

8/10

rate:

[Sharp]

I like it. The text and blue things fit well, but I would rotate the pink orbs in the BG on the right so it's not so obvious that it's the same as the foreground 8.5/10

[Bjarni]

Nice Sharp

But I think the left side is too bright

8|10

Rate:

[burningrock]

It's weird but cool in the same way! 8/10

[Briamoth]

Really nice. It flows well. But the render has a little flamey thing. Don't know if that was intended. Also, it's a little big but that's about it. 7/10

Rate:

[burningrock]

It was supposed to.

(Duplicate render layer twice run glass blocks on middle layer smudge on last layer and play with blending modes)

Next one rate Briamoth