Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[SkullSplitter]

1: Cool effects and I like the colors. What bugs me is that it looks like the thing's hand are missing.

The focal is centered but you made it work out. 8/10

2: I don't like this one as much. Some areas are too bright. It would look nice if you toned down the brightness a bit. 7/10

3: Nice blending and smudging, but too monotone for my taste. 8/10

Current: Too dark and the effects aren't as good as in the other ones. The text looks nice, though. 6.5/10

[FreE.MasoN]

Nice flow near the render, but it falls apart later sig and makes it look boring.

Nice try though .

[yy10]

Awesome sig. I don't think the colours fit though...maybe make it more orange-y? I really think you zoomed the render too much too. I can only see the head and it's quite boaring. 8/10

[Mendo]

i think i love it... there needs to be a bit more of the person and maybe a little more contrast although it's black and white, maybe some bright spots or something, i'm not really sure excellent job though 9/10

what's better current or this:

[theonlychad]

your current one is definitely better. I give the blue one 6/10 because it still needs a bit of work(there is no flow at all in that one)

Your current sig i give an 8/10 it has pretty good flow but it is still lacking something.

[Minoeman]

:o Cool sig. I like the colors and the text. Looks nice! And nice link box. 9.5/10

[Briamoth]

Pretty good sig could use some more effects and what not. Maybe work on the colors some also. Overall nice sig 7/10.

Please Rate This One and My Current Sig and Say Which Is Better:

[Zwicky]

First one: I like it, except the border is perhaps a little too clunky, and there's a weird black strip on the far right side? The text could be handled a bit better, very dominant and not too wonderful. The fading to a brighter yellow at the sides it a nice idea. 6.5/10

Current one: Definitely the better of the two, the border is a nice size, the green is not too bright and dominant. The text lets it down a bit though, if the render is supposed to the dominant point in the sig you shouldn't really make the text a new colour, let alone white, and place it on top of it, its too distracting. 7.5/10

[Sharp]

Zwicky: Cool sig, I like the purple flare in the BG. Although there is a little spot in the dropshadow/border thing in the bottom/middle that looks wierd. The text is really nice, looks very realistic and mettallic. 8.5/10

[FreE.MasoN]

Nice one, clean, simplistic and effective 8.5/10.

TPBM:

The effects on the persons arms ARE his arms :wink:

[yy10]

Nice sig. But it's too contrasted and quite strange. You should add some text or something. 8/10

(something random)

[pipp92]

way too random

the c4ds aren't matching in color

and the render/stock is really off

6/10

rate:

[Mendo]

don't ask why but i lke it 8/10..

this isn't a sig as it is the size of a billboard but it's going to be my new header for when

I restructure my gallery, what do you think?

and, please rate my current.

[The Stranger]

It's quite good, just take away some of the effects on top of the renders and a strong blue-ish gradient and it would look better! 8/10

Your current one is also quite nice, but try using more solid C4Ds as well. Experiment with different effects and C4Ds and you will get a lot better! 8/10

[Aislin]

nice use of colors, maybe is the av in the sig a bit too sharpen.....7/10

[Sharp]

I like the border, it looks like it's behind the forum. I can't really see the BG, but the text looks ok. 6.5/10

[Briamoth]

Nice sig. Love the contrast in it. 8/10

Rate This:

And Current. Tell Which Is Better Please.

[Sharp]

I like the first better. Maybe add some more fx over the bottom of the render, and tone down the yellow on the sides. The green one is way to saturated.

yellow 7/10

green 6/10

[Sfifer]

VVV Current one???

I like urs Sharp, very modern looking

[Bjarni]

Nice one Sfiffer, looks simple, but is great.

Nothing more to say...

9/10

[DarkShock]

A bit too blurry. It think it could also be a bit more artistic...

6.9/10

[Sharp]

Nice sig, but the proportions seem weird. Also the lines going out are too contrasted, as are the stars(?) in the bg. 8/10

[flip]

Pretty good, but I think the circles on the left shouldn't have the drop shadow. It makes it look too busy.

Render sig omgomgomgomg.

[Sharp]

Pretty good, but I think the circles on the left shouldn't have the drop shadow. It makes it look too busy.

They don't..?

Rate flip

[skylamer]

gewbd sig i rate 11/10