Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Zwicky]

I like it. The fade into black on both sides is perhaps a little abrupt (maybe a more gentle fade), but its good. Maybe something more fancy than a white semi-transparent tag in the corner in terms of text. Very good however! 9/10

[Sozo]

I really like the simplicity. 9.3/10

[Minoeman]

Holy cow. That is amazing. One of your bests. That is awesome. So plain, too. :wink:

Completely original, and I really don 't see anything wrong with it. COMPLETE 10/10.

[SkullSplitter]

Pretty nice. Looks original. I like the arrows and the splatter but it doesn't have a focal and the text in the middle (if it is text) is very hard to read. Also, I don't like the border and the colors don't match very well. 7/10. But that's just my opinion. I've seen better sigs from you.

PS: thanks for rating mine 10. I feel so proud

[Sharp]

The render is fuzzy, and the double render looks off, plus the text doesn't fit, but not bad overall 7.5/10

[Gamer_World14]

Nice and simple, like the blue color and rays, but try adding flow into the image with some brushes, smudging, or something else to draw the viewers to some sort of focal point. Good job overall, 8.6/10

Rate:

and current

|

|

V

[becauseiwantedto]

Nice and simple, like the blue color and rays, but try adding flow into the image with some brushes, smudging, or something else to draw the viewers to some sort of focal point. Good job overall, 8.6/10

Rate:

and current

|

|

V

Haven't both of those been rated enough? NEXT PERSON RATE GAMER_WORLD14

[Pride]

Ditch the white clouds and the border. Maybe add a bit of depth to it and also make the text smaller and slap it near the focal points.

8/10

[Minoeman]

Ooo, a little different this time, eh?

Though, that style of signature is getting old. Though the paint effects are nice, 8/10.

[Juraiko1324]

Pretty nice. the splatter-like strokes could use a duplicate layer, Gaussian blur, move layer down treatment...=)

I like how it goes of the border, and how you did the text. 9/10.

Is mine better yet? =D

[Pride]

Yep, I like how there's subtle depth in it. Although, it's either me or that the blood looks solidified. XD

9/10

[pipp92]

good flow good colours

but aliased text and oversharpened render

7.8/10

[Ouchy_S]

Pipp, you get a 8/10 from me. I love the effect used, and just the whole thing in general!

Rate this, please:

[Gamer_World14]

I like the background, but that render next to sonic is a bit too sharp. Nice job other than that, 8/10.

[Pride]

The block-like c4ds(?) overlaying the atmosphere is distracting. Maybe add a lens flare (I know there's a plug-in for it) at the edge of one of the mountains and it will be eye-candy!

EDIT: Woops forgot to add a score. 8.9/10!

[Minoeman]

I see nothing has changed. Signature are susposed to be art and creative

Not some crappy thing you see over and over again. "It's to plain," or "this and this distract the eyes," or how about "NO flow/focal/text/depth." Nye

Okay, somebody tell me. Is this picture art? I see no flow, no focal, and most certainly no depth.

Give this a think will yeah?

Next person rate pride.

[Pride]

About your post Minoeman, I know you don't need depth, flow etc. to have a good piece of art. But since we're supposed to be rating signatures on a fixed rating, there's not much we can do. I can give comments to all signatures in this forum saying that I can feel the artistic energy bursting from the canvas and to rate it 10/10 because everything is well, art.

[Minoeman]

I posted that for example. I'm trying to get everyone to start rating on Difference and originality.

Not the same thing over and over again.

[007 Nab]

The overlaying text in the example picture is depth, because it adds a medium of dimension to the picture.

I understand what you're saying, it would be nice if comments were a little more specific.

[Minoeman]

The overlaying text in the example picture is depth, because it adds a medium of dimension to the picture.

I understand what you're saying, it would be nice if comments were a little more specific.

Exactly!

Edit: Topic moved to here

[TopHATslash]

Prides sig is epic. 9.2/10. Work on the foreign character.

[pyrochild]

Pure awesome. Would be even better if the orb extended past the rest of the image (-1), but it's right-aligned in a left-justified world (+1).

10/10.

[K_I_N_G]

Not so original, not so good to look at, could have been done by a novice.

Just expected a little more from you.

This is an oldy from way back in the day. Rate:

[Pride]

Render is oversharpened. I like the text-ish background and the colour. Pretty neat!

8.5/10

[Juraiko1324]

9/10, could use more effects, BUT IT'S ORIGINAL AND CREATIVE.

Moi~?