Jump to content

Rate the sig of the poster above you!


Tendercrisp
 Share

Recommended Posts

Not my choice of color, or particular design for that matter but it shows detail and promise. The text, perhaps if placed with the flow of the render would give it an overall shine too it. Focal's weird haha, just seems to be at a strange place.

I give it a, 7.5/10. Overall its fairly decent. Just thought I'd point out the things I didnt like.

Suddenly having an angel rush. Rate this and my current please:

Angel_tears.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really good, little creepy though :wink:

9/10

I think your current sig is better though.

----------------. . . Smile . . . tomorrow will be worse . . .----------------

shinymount.png

---------------------. . . I'm a guy of simple tastes . . .----------------------

-------------------.:My Forever Maturing Gallery:.--------------------

Link to comment
Share on other sites

**********!!!! (10 stars) Hyrule, I love your signature! :P That wolf's so mean, he hates pollution and stuff!! P.S. rate my sig below me. :mrgreen:

sig-3.png

"Yep! Everyone loves dogs! And most of us love to know what heaven looks like! But however, there's one who thinks that "All Dogs Go to Heaven"! And that's me!" --Myself

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's a nice photo, and the background looks good.

If you took that photo, then 9/10.

If not . . . 7/10.

----------------. . . Smile . . . tomorrow will be worse . . .----------------

shinymount.png

---------------------. . . I'm a guy of simple tastes . . .----------------------

-------------------.:My Forever Maturing Gallery:.--------------------

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chazizzle: Very nice! 9/10 Maybe you could add something shiny in the middle like a meteor etc.

Pride: A bit too empty in my opinion but the text is nice.

Yougoboom: Looks cool 8.5/10. I like it but I'm not sure about the two white lines. The font looks cool though. Can anyone tell me what it's called?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can still see some of the color from where the signature was originally rendered. Not very apparent, but can really drag down the quality of a signature (its worth the extra effort to work on the render).

1st: 6/10. Original enough, but not my flavor. Not very much effort into lighting or blending so it comes off as a bit of boring.

2nd: Nice abstract, the text isn't correct though. Not pleasing to the eye, does this abstract encapsulate you? A signature is posted after everything you say, generally it should say something about yourself. 6/10 for effort, but not much skill. Practice.

My apologies if that was too harsh.

Yes, I'm a fan of the chick-flick Twilight, so I made a signature:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The splatter look is pretty cool, the black and white clouds in the bg doesnt quite fit with it though. Perhaps do a stone type of texture, like a grey background with the clouds set to overlay or a low transparency. Would bring out the splatter more I think.

7/10, its good but could use some color work.

I wasnt quite happy with the original so I made another:

Edward_Cullen_2.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7/10

Better, but get rid of the duplicated focal, you only need one, you've got 2. Not a good idea. ;)

bg is all right, and fx are.. low. Add some more fx on top, try using effect c4ds and not just brushes.

Text is much better, you're improving a lot. Just change the colours so they blend with the sig better. Black and white text on a blue sig doesn't really make sense imo.

Merry Christmas

 

.::.My Gallery.::.Make Gold Text!.::.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@KING: I don't like Edward Cullen . . . he's the reason boys these day's no longer have any charm, my girlfriend loves him :(

@Ouchy: I don't like the text, it's pretty distracting, but the rest of the sig is great.

8/10

Next person rate these two and my current please:

cloudedeyes.png

and

simple2.png

----------------. . . Smile . . . tomorrow will be worse . . .----------------

shinymount.png

---------------------. . . I'm a guy of simple tastes . . .----------------------

-------------------.:My Forever Maturing Gallery:.--------------------

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1: Thats pretty cool, looks like a sky texture. Perhaps a bit empty... 7/10.

2nd: Thats cool, looks like it was drawn on there. Give it a solid 8/10 for originality and pretty good execution. Perhaps the edges being cut off should be fixed though, give it a better outcome I think.

3rd: Could use some work, the planet look is cool but you only have a small part showing so it should be a little more spectacular. The edges of the planet seem to be bugging out or something. 7.8/10.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What i said before about the duped focal and the text still stands. I like this one more thought, its just seems more calmer and easier on the eye. Work with a smaller focal, or have a bigger canvas size thought. This one is almost square, most of your sigs are. If you've got a bigger canvas its easier to create depth as there's more space. Nonetheless, a healthy 7.5/10. :)

Merry Christmas

 

.::.My Gallery.::.Make Gold Text!.::.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8.5/10, for the reason that I really think it's a *tinytiny* bit too simple.... :S

Although, I would love to know how all of you antialias these things so well D: The pics look sosharp! :O

codeembersig.png

-I may have not been here when you passed away, but you will be missed.-

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...