Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Soap]

I love the back ground as well as your icon/text but for some reason they don't fit together enough imo. 8.03/10.00

[Down]

Soap: 7/10, even though all you did was add text, it looks nice.

[ShK_828]

9/10

it looks pretty good

[Minoeman]

It's good but the style is just not mine. 8.5/10

[Soap]

I love everything about the sig, except the creature is a bit blurry/indistinguishable(for those who don't know what it is) imo. 9.5/10

[petewolfbane]

good effects, but the background is just to monotone try adding C4D's.

still: 7.5/10

rate:

[ZizOiz]

Good render and matching background, but perhaps the render could be blended in using a greater variety of brushes. The bits of color all look similar to me. :? 7/10

[petewolfbane]

good sig, but the text is a bit unblended and adding a border would be nice.

7/10

rate:

[The Stranger]

8/10, to me the size is quite weird. nice work with the C4Ds though,guess you could put text and a border? and try soften portraiting the render

[ShK_828]

9.5/10

man, ur sigs are amazing, theyre so, pro >.>

[The Stranger]

thanks for the compliment shK_828, your sig has a quite a nice background, bad render , but just like topHATslash said to me BGs are nice but Focals are nicer, so a 7.5/10

so maybe put some effects, brushes etc, on top of your render too.

Rate:

[pipp92]

lovely sig you have there

the colors are really great

if you draw the anime 9/10

if not 8/10

[petewolfbane]

i like the way you smudged, but the background seems so empty try adding stuff to it like C4D's or brushes.

8/10

rate:

[pipp92]

try to make a better bg and try to blend your render more in

7/10

rate:

and

please

[S1nthora]

1. Sig: 5/10 Only Black-White.

2. Sig: 7/10 To much Smudge....

P.S: Wir sehen uns im Deutschen Forum

[petewolfbane]

nice sig i' m always of simplicity. although a border would be nice

8/10

rate:

and:

[S1nthora]

Oha...It's Guild Wars, isn't it? I love Guild Wars! ;-)

Mhhh....8/10

[pipp92]

mhh it's ok , i like the blurring edges

but please don't write 1 instead of i and so^^

6.8/10

rate:

[Minoeman]

That's cool. I like it. (The man's body is about to explode! lol) 9/10

[petewolfbane]

i already rated your's still the same

rate:

[Down]

Gw: 8/10

Bs: 6/10

Current:7/10

[petewolfbane]

i like the background, but the red dot is distracting.

8/10

rate:

[survulus]

9/10. The colours on the whole thing are pretty good. An interesting background but could overlap the initial picture a bit more clearly. Also some subtle text or some kind of title would be nice.

[JJgunz]

8/10 like the border and stars but try somethin different w/ text

rate:

i know, not my best work but, i got bored and was messin around

[TopHATslash]

I actually think its your best.. but it still has room for improvement. Try making it less monotone. I like the text. Work a bit on depth. Flow is cool. Altogether: 8.6/10

Oh and that smudge on the left is really outta place.