Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Yipppiyo]

5/10. The background is cool, but I didn't recognize which Pokemon it was. (didn't recognize that it was a Pokemon.) I think it would look a lot better with a better render of said Pokemon. The render itself doesn't have the detail to match the background.

Rate this please.

You aren't supposed to rate the render and the fact that it's pokemon. This is the ''Rate the Sig of the Poster Above you'' not Rate the Render.

[-Expiration-]

I see nothing wrong with his rating.

He was commenting on the render in relation to the rest of your sig, so basically, your composition. He stated that it was hard to recognize, probably because it was too small. He recommended getting a better render so it would fit better with the rest of your sig.

The render is a part of your sig, in fact, the main focus of it. How would not including it when rating be appropriate?

TPBM rate Scudder.

[rasengan105]

7/10 well made

[pipp92]

I like the shape and the depth in it, but it's too old.

7.5/10

[Uneyed]

I like the blending with the background. It gives the feel of fireworks falling all around the player. Yet it seems to obscure the player a little. The text is a bit blocky too. Overall - 3/5

[Aussi3ies]

9/10 Great!

I also checked out the stock.

[Artjom]

Really nice!!

9/10

[GuhhtarrPlayyurr]

8/10 Really good, and I like the background, but maybe fix up the border a little? I don't know something about it... :?

[pipp92]

It's too simple, i have nothing against simple ones, but if they are minimalistic, they should be clean and smooth. but it's your 100 post sig so 7/10

[Speed Demon]

im going to cop a pounding here! :oops: but anyway such is life

pipp92

Ronaldino is still the best and for that reason alone i am willing to give you 7. but those blurs in the background are great so i will make it a 9/10

[aeonix]

6/10

I really don't like....

[Aussi3ies]

I love this one! Great effects. 9.5/10

[rasengan105]

7/10 great grass effect

[LJXD]

10/10 love it

[ZELDA GURU]

9/10 I like the sphere, SHINY. :shock:

[Lego]

7/10, a lot of dead space, good background but I think using 3 renders in one signature is a little much...but with the size of your tag, I guess not...

[jedi12]

9.5/10 i really like it

[andROLL]

I don't know how I can explain why I like it, I just love it =D

well made

9/10

[Dr. Sat]

Simple shaped, cool, sexy.

9.5/10

You should make the white corners, like you did in the avatar.

And maybe the reflection but I'm not sure if it would fit.

[andROLL]

Looks Good, Though I'm not to keen on blurred edges.

7.5/10

TPBM rate both my current and this one please..

[Fire_Ants]

First: It's ok. Kinda boring, and a bit plain. Also, it would look a bit nicer if you had a border. Overall, I give it a 7/10

Second: It looks really good. I love the colors, and the background looks good, for being a somewhat simple effect. The only thing I don't like is the funky edges near the top and bottm, they really don't match.

Overall, 8.6/10

[RyuinfinityPDN]

6/10 overuse of brushes.

New sig/avvy set!

[Olli]

As said in avatar , its to much. try less effects and better colour matching

6.5/10

[scudder5000]

10/10. I really like it.

Rate this one please.

I don't know why I even made it.

[worldnewser]

Well I like the color scheme and the text. It matches Ivysaur well I also like your border. However, I think you went a bit too far with your fragmentation effect (as in there's too many).

8/10