Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[MIX_M@N]

The first one is lowered to a 8.5/10

There's a weird drop shadow thing in the top right...

Current is still a 10/10 :shock:

[Fire_Ants]

Interesting take on the Mikey D's Logo. The coke bottle seems kinda lonely, maybe add some fries on the right?

8.6/10

EDIT: You were faster MIX_M@N :o

I like it, looks like an oil painting 8.4/10

[Motoko21]

This is a signature I made for my game development studio.

The image is copyright to me and is 100% PDN.

[Champjev]

Ooooh very neat and shiny… 7/10

Here is a abstract:

{Ch@/\/\p}

[Motoko21]

8/10 for the first, very nice.

4/10, cause it's mcdonalds...

[MIX_M@N]

Very nice use of stock!

9/10

[dawmail333]

I find the transparencies look strange, it needs a background that blends well, there seem to be left over spots of colour around the letters that shouldn't be there, and a personal bias:

I really think that people's sigs/avatars shouldn't have the '300th post' type of thing in there. Making a new signature for your 300th post? Great! When showing it off here, say it! But why do you have to stick it in your signature? It just seems like pointless boasting (and clutter in my mind).

So, I'll give it a 5/10 for originality.

[Max Power]

I don't like the boarder and the boarder shape but still clean and tidy --> 7,9/10

[pipp92]

oh a new one

but i like it not really 6/10

[Motoko21]

Very nice, I like the depth it has. 8.6/10, It kind of looks like ice in a way...

Here's another signature I've been working on.

[Mr.Whiskers]

I Like that very much, its a good effect to have it standing out from the image. 8/10

[andROLL]

6,5/10

at first I saw the picture and thought ? but then i read your username, noww I get it =D

I like the effects, maybe a bit more skill you could learn and use? Also maybe a bit bigger?

I like it overall tho =]]

[Fire_Ants]

8/10

Looks good. The scanlines add a nice touch, too.

[MIX_M@N]

It's ok...

I think it's a bit too blue...

8.5/10

[Simon Brown]

4/10

I think it looks quite ugly i'm afraid.

[LFC4EVER]

9/10

Simple yet effective, i like the transparence on some of the text too (clever )

the background looks like some kind of silk cloth too..

[MiguelPereira]

7\10 cool composition, but way too much red, i know it's liverpool and all but, well... too much red

[Sozo]

7\10 cool composition, but way too much red, i know it's liverpool and all but, well... too much red

Best I've seen you do so far. 9.2/10!

[Champjev]

Well way outta my style once again and I made this abstract piece…

8/10 sozo

Am I good or getting better at sigs?

{Ch@/\/\p}

[drew]

You are pretty good at making sigs, but you need some different styles, shapes, and sizes. I like that sig with the different shapes, but I'm just ready to see some different type sigs.

6/10

[iKid]

5/10

I think its to plain :?

[drew]

It's not plain. It's simple. The best things in life are simple. I'm just a simple person. That's my style. Your sig is too plain. It looks like a blurry flower thing with a default font. I think your signature would look better if you added more effects (such as outlining, drop shadows, etc.). Paint.NET is very, very powerful and you (and everyone else) can create some awesome stuff!

I think your signature could be a bit better, so keep trying please! I'm ready to see your next signature! By the sound of your username, I picture like a techy sig. iKid sounds like iPod or iPhone. Both are modern and hi-tech devices.

Your current sig: 6/10

[jake2k]

8.5/10 cause I love minimalism and you did it very well

7.5/10 for iKid's cause it just looks cool haha, it could use a border (even just an overlay border like your avatar would be cool) and the font is kinda boring but thats an easy fix

[dawmail333]

Drew: slick, stylish and simple. A slight variation in the background there works well. 8.5/10

TPBM, rate both jake2k's and mine please, I've already rated his.

[Max Power]

My usual chart has to be enlarged for Jake... 0----------10--Jake

That's so awesome and so realistic I want a tutorial for this texture!

@Dawmail: your's has 7 of 10 jakes:

0 ------|-- Jake