Rate the sig of the poster above you!

[Champjev]

Here is a sig I made for my friend:

Fire Ants:

You are improving greatly man! The depth and efefcts in the epace are very sensual and warming and the flow isgreat!

9/10!

TLH:

Effects and flow is evry nice and the overall execution is unique

8.5/10

{Ch@/\/\p}

[jake2k]

I don't like the way the guys lookin at me plus it looks a bit too fuzzy and crowded so 5.5/10, maybe you should try upping the size on your next sig and see what you can do

Well after stating that I dislike those stock/abstract sigs I wondered if maybe everyone liked them cause they were fun to make so I made my own:

It really did nothing to change my opinion :? You can rate it if ya want, idk.

[Walrus]

Iron Man Sig: 9/10

[dawmail333]

Nothing really noticable that I can see. Nothing really to make it even stand out. When scanning through the page, I wouldn't even notice it. I can't say what's wrong in particular, but at least for me, it doesn't work.

Still not rating yet, and I wouldn't rate this one anyway. Will start rating again soon though.

New sig from me! (Those are the masks now in my Pictorium.)

[Champjev]

Lol jake I meant to have this rated! And nice attempt at stock pretty hard isn’t it?

Above: To simple but it has a nice look 6/10

{Ch@/\/\p}

[punisherjb]

hmm i like your sig a 8.5/10 just seems to crowded if though only one guy in it:P

[Dutch Man Dann]

@Champ: Once again, the off-kilter border annoys the bloody potato out of me. The girl is sort-of random...why is she showing off a phone? There really doesn't seem to be much to it. I am actually really sick of render sigs (and edited stocks) so that is why I am being harsh. Also I am terrible at render-sigs. 6/10.

@Punisher: Looks like a render thrown in to a stock background. Although the border is cool. 7/10.

I am in the process of creating imo my best Sig/avatar set I have ever made.It is a 300th post celebration...or whatever... It will probably be edited a few times after I get feedback, but It should be pretty much permanent...hopefully.

[Champjev]

Umm there doesn’t seem to be much to it? Where as I changed this to that sig?

Here is the original stock link:

http://i26.tinypic.com/11b2bty.jpg

You never know how much work is put into something unless you see the difference so next time think.. and just because you aren’t good at render or stock sigs and do not like them should not affect you’re rating it would be a bias but w.e

Bottom of me rate spirit.

{Ch@/\/\p}

[Yata]

I don't like render sigs. And your looking at it the wrong way: I don't like them because they have renders, and for some reason that just bothers me. It isn't biased, it's opinion.

5/10 for your current sig. I don't like the color contrast.

6/10 for the girl one. The phone seems random

[Sozo]

I never understood your current avy Yata, but I'll admit that the swirly backwash / ripply thingy does look cool. I'd rate it an 8.5/10, just because I'm not a fan of odd distorted text.

[Dutch Man Dann]

Umm there doesn’t seem to be much to it? Where as I changed this to that sig?

Here is the original stock link:

http://i26.tinypic.com/11b2bty.jpg

You never know how much work is put into something unless you see the difference so next time think.. and just because you aren’t good at render or stock sigs and do not like them should not affect you’re rating it would be a bias but w.e

Bottom of me rate spirit.

{Ch@/\/\p}

@Champ: Once again, the off-kilter border annoys the bloody potato out of me. The girl is sort-of random...why is she showing off a phone? There really doesn't seem to be much to it. I am actually really sick of render sigs (and edited stocks) so that is why I am being harsh. Also I am terrible at render-sigs. 6/10.

Half of the things I said are my opinion, and I said that I was being harsh and that is because I am terribly sick of render sigs. I also am starting to hate render sigs all together.

Also,I can base my rating off those facts. It would be equivalent to somebody saying " I hate pink, so 3/10" or "I hate grunge, 5/10".

I really don't want to get into an argument. I just am defending my opinion.

@CS: I really like the moon. The CS at the bottom looks like GS at first glance.It also looks a bit like the desktop background that comes on windows Xp... I love the colors. I love the border. I say 9/10

[jake2k]

I like the way it looks textured and how the "s" swirls around the cross but the mirrored text and chopped edges kinda take it down a bit 7.5/10

And nice attempt at stock pretty hard isn’t it?{Ch@/\/\p}

hahahahahahahahahahaharoflroflhaha, phew I almost fell out of my chair...

Dude they are way outdone and boring, and if you can do a little brushing, mess with colors and make abstract randomness then you can master them.

Now go and make a sig from scratch with a size of around 140x450 and tell me which ones easier to do, not to mention better looking

[Champjev]

Dude… making stuff from scratch is basically messing around until you come up with something.. unless you actually plan it out.. and trust me the stock one you made lacked depth a light source and a basic foundation and if it was on a real GFX site it would be a low rating… but w.e you have you’re opinion I got mine.

{Ch@/\/\p}

[lerp55]

9/10 really like the "border" "frame" idk exactly what you would call it-

- im not 100% happy with this criticism welcome

[dawmail333]

@Champjev

I'm not saying this because I have an anti-render bias, but your sig really doesn't work for me. I mean, it looks like you put 50 Cent up on a platform, put a Mandlebrot fractal next to him, and put a random lightsource in the background. I mean, what is it really meant to be?

@Lerp55

That's quite an interesting signature. It's got a consistent feel, and appeals to me anyway.

[Max Power]

@Champjev

I'm not saying this because I have an anti-render bias, but your sig really doesn't work for me. I mean, it looks like you put 50 Cent up on a platform, put a Mandlebrot fractal next to him, and put a random lightsource in the background. I mean, what is it really meant to be?

It's not even 50 cent. It's just another tough ghetto rapper :shock: (I think its Llyod Banks or so...)

I can really feel the coolness in champs signature. If you don't like those sigs his homies will make the streets bleed! Now you have beef with him! 8)

Get a sig or die tryin'!

{/\/\@><}

Yo!

[IceFusion]

@Max Power

Your sig is a bit small in my opinion, but I like the overall look of it. It seems to have a sense of depth in the text.

8/10

[dawmail333]

@MAX POWER

It's not even 50 cent. It's just another tough ghetto rapper

That's not the point.

If you don't like those sigs his homies will make the streets bleed! Now you have beef with him!

:? I think that's going a bit far...

And lastly, you missed the complete point of this topic: 'Rate the sig of the poster above you'

@IceFusion

If that's completely PDN, I'll eat my hat. 4/10 if it isn't, 7/10 if it is. Still pretty cool, but there are too many individual pixels showing. And is that a roof I can see?

[Among-Us]

its a nice sig 7.6/10

[dawmail333]

Well presented sig, everything fits well & compliments each other, but still very simple. 7/10

[Champjev]

Umm I didn’t use a manderbolt bold fractal or what ever… it is a custom brush…. That I made! And not a random light source and I made all of those effects around him… you have a really bad eye… and what is it meant to be? What is you’re meant to be?

Thanks Max

{Ch@/\/\p}

[Fire_Ants]

As usual, I always will have respect for you for finally bringing that style to these forums.

9/10

The only thing I might not like about your sig is the size. I know your used to smaller sigs/tags, but im used to larger sigs. But hey, if you like it, im cool with it 8)

[Dutch Man Dann]

I want to be able to make something like that. 9/10.

@jkae2k: What do you mean by chopped edges? I am making some changes to it anyways. It isn't going to say 300th post probably, and I am going to add a few "touch ups" to it.

~S x2~

[jake2k]

The top and bottom seemed to be cut off a bit thats all, happens to the best of us

[dawmail333]

I am REALLY starting to get annoyed about people who just post commentary about what other people have said and still miss the point of the whole topic:

Rate the sig of the poster above you!

Please, if you are going to post commentary, please at least rate. That goes especially to you Champjev.

@Champjev

It's supposed to be two masks (which I recently made) on a black, fading background, and a bit of text. Simple & easy, and it certainly doesn't seem 'crammed' to my eye like yours does.

Anyway you're supposed to take the constructive critism in this forum. When I said

I mean, it looks like you put 50 Cent up on a platform, put a Mandlebrot fractal next to him, and put a random lightsource in the background.

notice I said "it looks like..." not "you shouldn't have...". Please just take the critism you asked for when you came here, and be prepared to rate, not just argue with people every step of the way. I can practice what I preach: look below.

@Jake2K

Interesting, animated but you can tell where it's dithered as a gif, and almost none of it seems to be your work. Correct me if I'm wrong about that.

6/10 though for uniqueness.