Sign in to follow this  
chrisco97

Sig Battles (ENTRIES/VOTING ONLY)

Recommended Posts

I agree with Heat and Stone. I love it Axle:) Creative and perfect.

Axle: 3

N00bz: 0

#Winner Axle

I wish to enter this, my first NON-render sig:) Don't expect to win but here goes:

GBsig.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Camerator 1-0 mattz1996

camerator has a simpler look with the fading and text. i like the text mostly in it though

mattz, too much colour i must say and although the reflection is good, there wouldn't be a shadow at the base where neons meet neon-reflection. that was a bit of a mistake i feel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TOO MUCH render sigs lately and I like to see someone unique sorry chrisco but I like the simpleness of camerator

chrisco97:0

camerator:1

woot!! I now have 2 losses

Edited by N00Bz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@camerator: The colours are not very appealing and it looks rather unrefined.

It looks like the screw heads are just floating there. Also, you could work on anti-aliasing, try working large and then resizing.

@chrisco97: Very nice, my only nitpicks are that it feels like the glow is a bit too bright, and that Venom's left hand distracts from the focal a bit, at least for me. Great effects and nice text.

Vote goes to chrisco97.

camerator - 1

chrisco97    - 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

not needed anymore

I agree with Skullsplitter. camerator, if you fix it up a bit, and make it look more realistic, it will be a winner!

camerator - 1

chrisco97 - 2

Edited by Heat Stroke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mayor, I like it and it is really good. But it SkullSplitter's sig uses the stock in a more creative way. Plus, I like SkullSplitter's text and border. Great job!

Mayor_McSteeze: 0

SkullSplitter: 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mc_steeze: 1 very nice and somehow the purple suits it

SkullSplitter: 1 not too appealing and im not sure which is pdn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mayor: 3

SkullSpltter: 1

Mayor's has better quality overall. Only thing I'd change is the text location, I'd move it closer to the render.

And so Mayor McSteeze wins.

#winner Mayor McSteeze

gorillalowcontrast.png

Edited by Kemaru

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kemaru: 0

Axle: 1

--

Kemaru, your's is too bright, and I do not like the reflection thing on the left. If you would have entered the other one, you would have gotten my vote.

Axle, nice simple render sig. Only thing I would change is the text placement. As barbieq25 said, move it over about 10 px to the right.

Edited by chrisco97

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kemaru: 0

Axle: 1

--

Kemaru, your's is too bright, and I do not like the reflection thing on the left. If you would have entered the other one, you would have gotten my vote.

Axle, nice simple render sig. Only thing I would change is the text placement. As barbieq25 said, move it over about 10 px to the right.

Pretty much agree with that. I like Axle's text, but it needs to be moved over a little.

[my bad -- 2-0 axle]

Edited by Stone85

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with Chrisco as well. Asuming Stone voted for Axle:

Kemaru: 0

Axle: 3

#winner Axle

I will enter:

deadpool_sig_final.png

Edited by Heat Stroke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chrisco97 - 1

Heat Stroke - 0

Oh wow, this one's difficult. However I think Chrisco97's sig is better because overall it has better depth and lighting, although it is coming from the wrong side. The light source should be at about 45-50 degrees above the render's eye level, slightly behind him as well. Your sig could also manage without a border, though that's just my personal preference.

Heat Stroke, like I said in the RTSOTPAY-thread (or it might have been in the pictorium), you could try using a different approach to enhancing the render. The vignette is really rough and I think that a simple 2px Gaussian blur on the left side would have been better.

EDIT: Oh, and you both need to work on the text placement and on the text itself. Using blending modes is generally a bad idea. Try to pick a bright colour from somewhere in the sig and use that. Most of the time it will fit the colour scheme. A good tip is to find a bright or a vibrant colour in your sig and place it in a dark or an unsaturated spot close to the focal point.

Edited by Kemaru

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

they're both nice sigs but i have to say that i like 'America' more

Heat Stroke < Chrisco97

0 < 2

EDIT: oops

Edited by Axle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like both of the sigs are really well excuted however the america sig had abit more depth, and better lighting.

Heat Stroke: 0

Chrisco97: 3 ( Look at the two post above me, axle forgot to add 1 )

winner #Chrisco97

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this