Sign in to follow this  
chrisco97

Sig Battles (ENTRIES/VOTING ONLY)

Recommended Posts

Stone:

Text & Or Border 5/15

Color Scheme 7/10

Textures & C4d's 10\20

Compostion & Flow 7/15

Quality 6/10

Execution 6/10

Concept 6/10

Unique & Eyecatching 5/10

Overall 52/100

Psycho:

Text & Or Border 2/15

Color Scheme 2/10

Textures & C4d's 7\20

Compostion & Flow 3/15

Quality 6/10

Execution 3/10

Concept 6/10

Unique & Eyecatching 5/10

Overall 34/100

Stone:1

Psycho:0

Edited by Mayor_McSteeze

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Stone85 gmv. Ima do a detailed explanation and cnc lol

Stone85: You're definitely improving. You have some nice effects. Your colours look simple and they can blend with the render and the background. However, the black fading outline/border in the on the edges of the sig does not fit with the sig and ruins it. Your text is still at a beginner's stage so may I suggest you not to add text to your sigs. I'm not goingto point out that the render looks stretched because it's not really that important. Keep reading some basic signature tutorials and if you really want to get into makinng small art, start vising more forums. :)

PsychoHarmonic: From what I can see, you have a nice potential. It's great you're using some simple stocks to make your sig. Though if I were you, I wouldn't have used that concept. Those colours don't fit and they look very random. The text ruins the whole sig also. As I said to Stone above, read more basic tuts. :)

Stone: 2

Psycho: 0

Anyone wanna battle me next round...?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest PsychoHarmonic

Stone 3

Psycho 0

I like the effect psycho. but it's to simple (and random).

#winner Stone95

Anyone wanna fight my new sig (I need the feedback :))?

Neo%20Sigi.jpg

Thanks random is what i was going for =D

Im gonna have to go with ptuZ on this one.

The reasons being that Musiphonix's sig is jaggy, and it looks like the center is poler inverted and sigs are not big enough for that.

ptuZ zig of the other hand is nice. I like the foreground but, the darkness/contrast take too much away from the background.

ptuZ: uno

Musiphonix: ZIP

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ptuz:2

musiphonix:0

ptuz i like it its simple but good. it could be a little lighter though. just my opinion

musiphonix: to much going on and the font is kinda hard to read

Edited by paint dot mike

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I vote Ptuz. You should add a second light source to the left though so you can see the people.

Musi- I don't really like the text and it looks like you resized the sig because it looks like the quality was reduced.

#winner Ptuz

Stone85CreedSig.png?t=1284190111

I use text cuz I really wanna get better with it.

I'm likin' the new (i think it's new....) sig, Mayor. boltbait.wink.png

yy10- I can never find any good pdn render sig tuts. Got any? Or any that are on another program but can be done on pdn?

Edited by Stone85

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

>>>Stone85>>>0 nice, but needs a little more blending with the edges

>>>Mayor_McSteeze>>>1 as i said in the 'rate the sig above you' it looks nice but is lacking some text

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

>>>Stone85>>>0 nice, but needs a little more blending with the edges

>>>Mayor_McSteeze>>>1 as i said in the 'rate the sig above you' it looks nice but is lacking some text

I know, but im unable to install fonts, and the basic fonts are suckish so i just don't use them. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest PsychoHarmonic

stone-0

Mcsteeze-2

stones sig just don't have this "pop" factor like mayors.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Stone gmv. One of the great sigs I've seen on this forum///

Stone- 1

Mcsteze (dunno how to speel your name sorry)- 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know, but im unable to install fonts, and the basic fonts are suckish so i just don't use them. :D

what do you mean you can't install new fonts??

and i'll enter my new Pixel Meteor (or whatever you think it is) in

pixelworxs.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have to say which sig you are entering and put it in your post, Dr.Grit. That's a casual warning.

Did you even make that in PdN?

Thats 2-1 Axle...

More professional and much sexier.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest PsychoHarmonic

BOOOOM!!!

battling with current

hulksig.png

P.s

Pyrochild you took my last comment out of context. I was sad you didn't vote not mocking the new rules. But either way i am sorry i upset you.

Edited by PsychoHarmonic

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This thread is for entries and voting only. Everything else goes in the Discussion thread. So shut up, y'all!

EDIT: The next person to test my patience by saying, "but pyrochild, you did not enter or vote," gets to be the first on this forum to try out moderator preview. That means a mod has to approve each and every post you make before it shows.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

paint dot mike: 1

PsychoHarmonic: 0

paint dot mike's has a simple design, it is clean, and overall blends well. Best one from him yet.

PsychoHarmonic, not a bad sig, but the render is poor quality, the text looks pasted on, and the c4d is hardly edited. But, I give you props for effort.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this