Nitenurse - I really like rainbows and the reflection below your text is quite well done. Overall a nice looking sig.
JulioCoolio - A very simple sig, I really like the glossy, 3D effect you have on the text, but I don't really like the test itself, it reminds me a little of comic sans. It's a really good looking sig but I would've liked it better if the font had been different.
The score is now:
Nitenurse - 1
JulioCoolio - 0