Assuming that Axle's is 100%, I like his more. It looks very time consuming and creative, but most of all it's a very unique sig.
I like the way N0O0O0O0O0OBz smudged the render, but the background doesn't really fit. I like what you did with the render, I tried to use that same render before and it didn't work good. The background just doesn't really seem to go with the render, but it could be a good sig with some minor changes.
1-0 Axle