Okay so I have recently taken it upon myself to fix up the like and dislike buttons on one of the forums I use to match our theme. The only issue is I'm quite incompetent at it. So I'm going to be posting some pictures for you to see and I hope one of you kind people will be able to help me out (actually do it yourself or give me some pointers).
Original Images
Sample Buttons (what I want them to resemble)
My pitiful Attempts