22 replies to this topic

[bugman]

Hi

I am wondering why the gradients that paint.net generate look so dull, and i've experimented with creating the gradient by just filling two colors and then applying gaussian blur. Is there a reason why the gradient looks dull? and is there already a tool for creating a gradient like a gaussian blur provides?

it looks like the gradient tool creates a lot of "in between" color, in my example gray.

I've attached an example. The gadient is on the left, gaussian blur on the right.

Attached Thumbnails

• 

[Ego Eram Reputo]

I'm thinking that your gradient is stretched out more than the blur (which blurs the border between the two colors).

Try the gradient again and this time don't drag the start/finish nubs so far. Keep them more central.

[bugman]

I'm thinking that your gradient is stretched out more than the blur (which blurs the border between the two colors).

Try the gradient again and this time don't drag the start/finish nubs so far. Keep them more central.

This is not the issue at hand. If you try to edit the image you can see that the colors change throughout the height of the image in both cases.
What I think is the explanation is that the gaussian blur formula does not blend linear, and the gradient does

Now i'm just wondering if it wouldn't be a nice option to have when making gradients that you can select linear or gaussian blending? or is it just me that thinks that the gaussian blur looks much better?

[Ego Eram Reputo]

I'm still convinced that it's to do with the length of the gradient vs the blur.

[bugman]

I'm still convinced that it's to do with the length of the gradient vs the blur.

You can use the PDN color picker with 0 tolerance on the image i've attached. It's pretty clear that the color changes throughout the image height in both cases.

[Rick Brewster]

Onoz, the gradients look so dull. Onoz indeed, whatever shall we do. *something about the British drinking tea and saying onoz, I don't know why but it sounds funny*

Try something like this out: draw the gradient it on its own layer and use something like Brightness/Contrast or Curves to adjust the effective gamma ramp.

Gradients are drawn with a linear ramp, like you mentioned.

[BoltBait]

bugman, will this do?

http://forums.getpai...radient-plugin/

Let me know.

[bugman]

bugman, will this do?

http://forums.getpai...radient-plugin/

Let me know.

Wow. That's really nice. Just what I had in mind. Thanks a lot, I hope it will be useful to other people too. I think it would be a great addition to the standard gradient tool.

[Rick Brewster]

BTW I am considering some additional Gradient tool options for a post-4.0 release. Choosing the "gamma ramp" method (linear, quadratic, ...) is among the properties I'm considering. (The code is easy, but I gotta make sure the toolbar doesn't overflow.)

[minners71]

Onoz, the gradients look so dull. Onoz indeed, whatever shall we do. *something about the British drinking tea and saying onoz, I don't know why but it sounds funny*

Try something like this out: draw the gradient it on its own layer and use something like Brightness/Contrast or Curves to adjust the effective gamma ramp.

Gradients are drawn with a linear ramp, like you mentioned.

I'm british and have never said onoz while drinking tea

[welshblue]

I'm british and have never said onoz while drinking tea

Me neither.

[BoltBait]

Maybe you should try it.

[welshblue]

I'll give it a miss. Onoz sounds like an indigestion remedy ...

[barbieq25]

Me neither.

Is British not same as Ingerlish? Not being a smarty here just wondering.

Never heard of the whole thing but them I'm from the land down under...

[Ego Eram Reputo]

... I'm from the land down under...

..where the beer does flow and men chunder. Can you hear, can you hear the thunder? You better run, you better take cover. (Men at Work)

[barbieq25]

..where the beer does flow and men chunder. Can you hear, can you hear the thunder? You better run, you better take cover. (Men at Work)

Ah, looks like chunder must be universal. I'll hand you a vegemite sandwich

[welshblue]

Is British not same as Ingerlish?

Britain is the collective name for Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Ingerland ... although most people describe themselves as from the country of birth not as being British.

Edited by welshblue, 29 April 2012 - 10:06 AM.

[Djisves]

I was under the impression that Britain (however great or little) is the island east of Ireland.
The "collective name for Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Ingerland" is the UK. Hence the official name: The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

[Rick Brewster]

Ok I see to have derailed this thread. Sorry about that

Onoz is the plural form of "oh no," and is tongue-in-cheek. It's not actually British.

[minners71]

^ Ban him !..................................................................................................jk

I am in fact Ingerlish not British